Renewable Energy III: Energy Storage

As we have learned over the past few weeks, light and wind can be transformed (by a solar cell or wind turbine, respectively) into usable electrical energy which can, in turn, be used to power things like a light bulb. However, as soon as the sun goes down or the wind slows, the electricity stops flowing. Can we store energy for use later?

In this lab, you will design a system for capturing and storing energy to use to run your light bulb later (when your “sun” or “wind” go away). You will study how energy is changed from one form to another, and calculate the efficiency of each step in the process.

An example of a real-world gravitational potential energy “battery” (sort of like what you are going to build today) is this new project in Switzerland! (Maybe turn the computer volume down or off… there are no words, just music.)

Another common method of energy storage is pumping water into a reservoir to be used by a hydroelectric generator later. You can even make a scale hydroelectric dam with Lego™ that can light up an LED or two (similar to your experiment today).

By the end of this lab, you will have…

  • … observed the transformation of energy between different types (light, electrical, gravitational potential, kinetic, rotational, etc.);
  • … stored energy for later use in a water reservoir “battery”;
  • … practiced engineering and experiment refinement by building towards a design goal; and
  • … calculated efficiency stage-by-stage for a multi-step process.

Procedure


You will again work in groups of three. The TA will introduce the equipment available and guide you through the lab. This time, the focus of the experiment is on designing and modifying equipment to achieve a goal – namely, to store energy which can be used to light a bulb after the “sun” has gone down or the “wind” has died down. You will be working with either solar panels or the wind turbine to power a hydraulic pump. The pump is used in turn to store water in a “reservoir” which can later be released to turn a turbine and light an incandescent bulb or LED.

It will be best to work on this project in steps: get the first piece of the design working before moving on to the next. At each stage you can consider the transfer of energy from one form to another. Remember that sometimes you measure power, P, (e.g. electrical power, P = IV, where I is current and V is voltage), and sometimes you are measuring energy, E, (e.g. gravitational potential energy, E = mgh, where m is mass, g is the acceleration due to gravity, and h is the height.) Be sure to keep these quantities straight, remembering that they are related by P = E/t or E = Pt, where t is time.

Calculate efficiency, $\eta$ at each step, as the ratio of energy out to energy in, or the ratio of work done to work put in: $\eta = E_{out}/E_{in} = W_{out}/W_{in}.$ In addition to calculating the efficiency at each step, calculate the final overall efficiency.

Again, don’t forget to record everything you do in your lab notebook, and to prepare you most important results on the whiteboard for discussion at the end of the class.

Group lab notebook

Remember to write down everything you see and do in your group lab notebook.

  • Make sketches, do calculations, take notes, and record observations. Your TA may ask to see your notebook during lab, and will read over it afterwards to assign a grade to the group.
  • Use the digital group lab report to communicate the process and results from your experiment.
  • Designate one member of the group to be the official record keeper. This person will be the main typist for the group, but all members are expected to contribute, read over, and comment on the report and all members of the group will receive the same report grade.

Outline of the lab

Make preliminary observations

Consider: How does each section of the setup transmit energy to the next section? What different ways have you learned to measure work and power in previous labs that might be applicable here?

Modify the setup

Consider: What changes can you make to the setup to produce more power at the end? Consider each step individually. What parameters will increase efficiency at each step or increase overall power delivered?

Measure efficiency

Consider: Are you choosing the right quantities to monitor? When do you need to record the time of different processes, and when is it fine to work only with power?

Analyze your results

Consider: How can you represent your results? What have you learned about the efficiency of this energy storage method? Do you trust these results? Why or why not? Do you believe that the efficiency results you measured here represent the efficiencies of real energy storage systems in use today? Why or why not?

Tips for making voltage and current measurements

One of the important quantities you will want to measure today is the electrical power ($P$) delivered by your solar panel. In electrical circuits, work is done by moving electric charges around. Mathematically, power is work done ($W$) per unit time ($t$) (or equivalently, energy transferred, $E$ per unit time):

$P = W/t = E/t$.

Electrical power (usually measured in units of watts, W) is calculated as the product of voltage ($V$, usually measured in units of volts, V) and current ($I$, usually measured in units of amps, A) as

$P = IV$.

In order to measure these quantities, we provide a small measurement board and two meters. The board has the following four connections:

  • Source: Connect your source (e.g. your wind turbine or your solar cell) here.
  • Load: Connect the “thing” you want to power with your circuit (e.g. a fan, a lightbulb, or an LED) here.
  • Voltage: Connect a meter (set to DC voltage on the 20 V range) here.
  • Current: Connect a meter (set to DC current on the 200 mA range) here.

We show a schematic and a photo of these connections in the figure below.

A schematic (top) and a photo (bottom) showing how to wire your circuit in order to measure both current and voltage with the meters. In this example, the ammeter reads a current of $I$ = 6.4 mA and the second meter reads a voltage of $V$ = 3.35 V. That means the total power is $P = IV$ = 21.4 mW. (Click on the photos to expand.)

Your measurement board may have red & black connectors, orange & grey connectors, or orange & brown connectors; all boards work the same. Plug all your red cables into one color (e.g. red or orange) and plug all the black cables into the other color (e.g. black, grey, or brown).

Conclusions


At the end of the lab, you will need to record your final conclusions (about 1 or 2 paragraphs) in your lab report summing up the important results and take-away points from your experiment. Remember that you should only draw conclusions which are supported by the data, so be ready to back up any statements you make!

When you're finished, save your file as a PDF and upload it to Canvas. (Only one student needs to submit the report, but make sure everyone's name is on it!) If you make a mistake, you can re-submit, but work done after the end of the lab period will not be accepted.

Remember to log out of all your accounts after you submit!